This second book in the Clocktaur War duology begins where the first one ended, with the four protagonists arriving in Anuket City and starting their undercover work to sabotage the dangerous clocktaurs. Learned Edmund enrolls the help of a master artificer, Ashes Magnus (discovering to his enormous surprise that she’s a woman, and therefore further eroding his misconceptions about the other sex), while Slate, Brenner and Caliban must infiltrate the city’s seedier quarters in search of information while Grimehug, the gnole they encountered along the way and who attached himself to Slate, is revealed as a very helpful co-conspirator.
As for Slate, the dangers inherent in returning to Anuket City, which she left to escape the retaliation of crime lord Horsehand, manifest quite suddenly and with potentially deadly consequences, while the foursome’s investigation on the origin of the clocktaurs leads to a terrible discovery and a dangerous infiltration mission from which not all of them will return…
Much as I enjoyed the first part of this duology, I have to admit that this second installment, while still reasonably engaging, did not work as well: for starters, the growing attraction between Slate and Caliban did not feel quite integral to the story, and it pushed the true reason for the quartet’s mission somewhat in the background. It was not because of my aversion to romance, because usually T. Kingfisher manages this element quite well in balancing it with a good dose of humor, but rather because there were no sufficient elements in the relationship to make it believable: there is no doubt about the mutual physical attraction, but their personalities are often in conflict, with no apparent possibility of common ground on which to establish a love story – this is quite different from other relationships portrayed in Kingfisher’s later books, and a bit disappointing. On top of that, the rivalry between Caliban and Brenner over Slate’s affections moves from the first book’s amusingly barbed banter into what looks like hormone-fueled clashes, sliding into the trope of the love triangle and robbing this side of the story of its entertainment value.
Luckily for me, I could focus on the very intriguing aspect of gnole culture: thanks to Grimehug we are made privy to the rich and layered gnole society and the way these creatures, alternately despised, feared and ignored, have carved their niche into human society. Grimehug himself is a delightful character, particularly when he shares his (not very flattering) views on humanity’s behavior, and I liked the way he attached himself to Slate: the bond of friendship between them was indeed one of the higher points in the story, as was Learned Edmund dedication in compiling a treatise on gnoles so that they could be better understood – and appreciated.
When not mooning over Slate, Caliban offers another interesting peek into the paladin mentality, particularly where the connection to one’s god is concerned: there is a fascinating dichotomy here, because on one side we are told about this connection to the divine and the constant battle with demon possession, on the other a paladin’s role seems mostly mundane – at least according to Caliban whose activities largely consisted in the exorcism of possessed animals. And yet, Caliban feels the absence of his god most keenly, and at one point seems almost tempted to accept the offer of another god to fill that void – which made me wonder if his attachment to Slate was not an attempt to do exactly that, rather than a genuine feeling…
Story-wise, The Wonder Engine sees the culmination of the four characters’ mission and the discovery of what originated the creation of the clocktaurs, and does so with a good deal of suspense laced with humor that kept me turning the pages at a fast pace: the steampunk element introduced with the clocktaurs is a nice touch in this fantasy setting and also adds a few gory details that heightened the tension. I must add that there is a surprise development concerning one of the main characters which I suspected must be there since the first book, but still managed to appear surprising thanks to its unexpected placement in the story: without spoiling the surprise, I have to say that Slate’s reaction to this revelation and its consequences played very well and served to depict her personality even more accurately.
When all is said and done, I enjoyed the conclusion of the duology even though it did not feel on the same level as other works by T. Kingfisher: still, the entertainment value of her stories remains high and I’m not going to let this slightly disappointing encounter distract me from reading her other novels.
Glad this wasn’t a let down.
I do have to ask, was this and the previous book one giant book cut into 2 parts, or does each have its own separate identity?
LikeLiked by 1 person
The publishing date for the books separates them between 2017 and 2018, so one might say it’s two books, but the way the story goes makes me think about one single story divided in two, with the first one ending in something of a cliffhanger. Thankfully for me, there was no waiting time… 😉
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s what I wondered and a mere year between tends to confirm that suspicion.
Thanks 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Grimehug is an awesome name, or awful, I’m not sure yet.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I vote for awesome. But an awful sensation.
LikeLiked by 1 person
😂😂😂
LikeLike
Name aside, the character is nothing short of delightful, so… a gnole by any other name… 😉
LikeLike
I am glad you still enjoyed it, even if it was somehow disappointing!! I have yet to start this series, but it is waiting on my e-reader for its turn, and I am so looking forward to it!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
All things considered, it’s a very entertaining read and what disappointment I expressed comes from my expectations, not because of poor book quality…
LikeLiked by 1 person
Glad you still enjoyed it despite the disappointments, Maddalena!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Those disappointments were really minor, and the overall story was still quite good 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
The gnoles are one ot my favorite parts of the White Rat books!
LikeLiked by 1 person
They are quite adorable, but so are all of the animal-like companions I encountered in previous Kingfisher books 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m glad you enjoyed this even with some negatives. I’m tempted to try this duology at some point!
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s well worth your time: my (slight) disappointment came from my expectations after book 1, but still I enjoyed book 2 and would still recommend it 🙂
LikeLike
Interesting notes on the romance! I personally find it hard to get attached to romances where the MCs’ personalities clash, and the author just chalks it up to ‘opposites attract’ or something like that. 😅 I do want to read from T Kingfisher though. Which of their books would you recommend I start with instead? 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
The first Kingfisher book I read – and the one that turned me into an instant fan – was Nettle & Bone: I recently recommended it to a friend and she loved it – to date it’s still her favorite. Then The Seventh Bride or the first Paladin book – Paladin’s Grace – might be good choices as well. Happy reading! 🙂
LikeLike
Oooh I am sorry it didn’t work as well as the first instalment! I recall you saying it had be the funniest book of Kingfisher!
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s still fun and I enjoyed it nonetheless, but this time focus on the love story robbed the novel of its previous tongue-in-cheek “flavor”. I usually enjoy Kingfisher’s love entanglements, but in this instance there was less humor than I’m used to, and that weighed on my rating.
LikeLike
Another one of Kingfisher’s that I need to explore. But I do tend to prefer her more recent horror to her whimsical fantasy romances.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The only Kingfisher horror-themed book I read was A House With Good Bones, and while I liked it, I believe I will keep to her fantasy novels… that is, unless one of your horror recommendations make me change my mind! 😉
LikeLike
Ah… it’s sometimes tricky to manage expectations after having such a fabulous reading experience with an author. I felt a bit the same way with Martha Wells’ Witch King. I love the Murderbot books and her Il-Rien series blew me away, so I came to the Witch King with huge anticipation. And found it difficult to bond sufficiently with the MC to really care as much as I needed to throughout. That said – this is a duology I’ve put on my Wish List:)).
LikeLiked by 1 person
I would still strongly recommend this duology despite its few… hiccups: I believe that part 1 sets the expectations a little too high so that part 2 seems a little disappointing, but overall it’s your typical, engaging Kingfisher tale 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
And that’s good enough for me! Thank you, Maddalena:).
LikeLiked by 1 person
She is usually something of an expert at managing the romance elements.
Still a winning duology even with a little dip with this one.
Lynn 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
It was a fun journey and I never for one moment regretted having started it 🙂
LikeLike