Reviews

FOUNDATION (Apple TV+) – Season One – #SciFiMonth

Without doubt, this is one of the most anticipated TV series for this year, and at the same time a quite controversial one: while I read Asimov’s saga a few decades ago and therefore forgot most of its details, there are people who are quite conversant with it, and they have been quite vocal in their displeasure about the way this story has been translated to the small screen.  My lack of familiarity with the original material did somehow work in my favor as I watched this first season: once I realized that it was going to be quite different from Asimov’s works, no matter how much of it I remembered, I decided to simply sit back and enjoy it nonetheless – and ultimately I did, although I have to admit it was something of a complicated journey.

The core concept, which Asimov drew from Gibbons’ Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, is that of a vast galactic empire whose end has been forecast by scientists Hari Seldon through the application of psychohistory, a mathematical predictive model applied to large social groupings and able to foresee the development of future events. Seldon affirms that the fall of the Empire will bring a new Dark Age that might last for millennia, proposing the creation of a huge encyclopedic project – the Foundation – to preserve knowledge and shorten the dark ages before civilization can rise again.  Seldon and his followers are exiled to the planet Terminus, there to collect such knowledge into the Galactic Encyclopedia, and to remove their destabilizing presence from the Emperor’s sight.

Asimov’s original work proposed a series of temporal leaps in which the reader could follow the Foundation’s progress over the centuries and the inevitable collapse of the Empire, and as such it certainly presented a narrative (and character) continuity problem for the televised format, and so the series’ creators choose to keep the author’s basic concept and move from there toward a different path – choice that caused the displeasure of many fans of the author.  Personally I did not dislike this path, particularly where the theme of the Empire’s genetic dynasty is concerned: it is stipulated in the series that each emperor is a clone of the original founder, Cleon, and that he’s present in three different stages of his life – youth (brother Dawn), maturity (brother Day) and old age (brother Dusk) – thus allowing the effective ruler, brother Day, to always wear the same, recognizable face, while at the same time offering an intriguing narrative device through many reflections about the continuity of power and the prices to be paid to maintain it.

Another change comes from the decision to gender-switch a few key figures to create some much-needed character balance which the core material lacked, given that it was a mirror of its times and worldview, particularly where SF was concerned. And so we have the human-looking robot Demerzel, who acts as a combination protector/companion/guide to the various Cleons through the ages, and who quite intriguingly mixes an apparent coldly calculating exterior with some deep feelings and even religious beliefs.  Then there is the young mathematical prodigy Gaal Dornick, who finds herself caught in Seldon’s project and ends up challenging its apparent ineluctability. And again Salvor Hardin, possessed with the heart of a warrior and the drive to keep her people on Terminus safe from any danger.

Visually, the series is nothing short of stunning and you can see that it received a conspicuous budget to carry on its goal: alien landscapes and civilizations, gorgeous costumes and incredible ships, not to mention everything related to Trantor, the imperial planet built of so many levels that only the most fortunate can enjoy the true light of day while others spend their entire lives seeing only the holographic representation of what the outside world could be. And yet, behind this beautiful façade something seems to be missing: for me it was a strong connection with the characters, because the constant changes of scenery and the time jumps did not leave me enough time to explore them as individuals, to understand their motivations or to perceive their feelings.  These characters rarely feel like people, often driven to the discussion of deep, far-reaching issues but seldom coming forward as living, breathing individuals – if I’m making any sense here…

The story’s rhythm also feels off for most of the time, with sections that move at a glacial pace only to be followed by rapid changes of scenery that might appear unconnected to the entirety of the narrative: it’s only with the eight episode of the series that finally all those apparently disconnected threads start to take shape and to show that the ambitious – but slightly unfocused – design at the root of this first season is heading in a particular direction.  With only ten episodes for the season this choice looks like a huge risk, because I can’t help but wonder how many viewers the story lost along the way because of that lack of cohesive focus – I know, because I came close to that point and now that this overlong “prologue” is over I’m glad I soldiered on and can hope that with season two we’ll be able to find a stronger storytelling method that will be able to fulfill the promises laid down by this somewhat shaky opening.

There is some hope that now that the foundations (sorry, no pun intended!) of the story have been set in place, the series will be able to carry on in a more organic and more narratively satisfying way: the last three episodes have strengthened this hope, so I’m looking forward to seeing what the next season has in store for us viewers…

My Rating:

And with this post ends the latest iteration of SciFi Month, one of the two pivotal bookish events I look forward to each year. As usual it was fun to roam through strange worlds and weird backgrounds and for this we have to thank once again our hosts IMYRIL and LISA whose guidance always steered us true and prevented us from falling into a black hole or to be snatched by a temporal anomaly 🙂

Until next year!

ARTWORK by Liu Zishan from 123RF.com

30 thoughts on “FOUNDATION (Apple TV+) – Season One – #SciFiMonth

  1. During the first few episodes I was quite invested and I liked what they did with the Emperor. I was writing a review as well. But around episode 4 or 5 I got more and more frustrated and in the end I abandoned the show and deleted my review. I think my greatest problems were the writing in the scenes on Terminus and the acting by some of the main characters on Terminus. Those parts felt very wooden and didn’t convince me.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. The Terminus sections felt very strange to me as well, mostly because I did not feel they were doing much about their project, apart from talking about it. And while I enjoyed the idea of Salvor Hardin as a protector/warrior, there was something missing there, even though I have not been able to pinpoint what it was. Only the next season will tell us if these problems were simple “growing pains” or if the storytelling is inherently faulty…

      Like

      1. One thing I noticed about the Salvor scenes is that everybody kept telling her that she “was special”, “was destined for great things”, “was a natural leader”. But we didn’t really get to see this and the actress wasn’t good enough to pull this off. These kind of things should work subconsciously, in a show-don’t-tell way. Otherwise it is not believable.

        Liked by 1 person

        1. Yes, that “chosen one” vibe did not work well – or as well as the creators intended anyway – and from the comments I read online it was one of the reasons this character did not encounter the favor of a number of viewers. Given the revelation offered in the last episode, it will be interesting to see where her “special powers” take her 🙂

          Like

  2. Thanks for this review. I don’t have apple tv, but if this ever gets streamed elsewhere, I’ll be sure to avoid it 🙂
    While I’m not a huge Foundation fan, I am big enough of one that all the changes you mention would drive me crazy.

    Sometimes it is nice to not be a big fan and to just be able to enjoy something without any attached baggage.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. It was a shared opinion that Asimov’s Foundation series would be difficult (if not impossible) to film, given its episodic nature, so great changes were practically unavoidable in the translation to screen, but if the series manages to take flight in the next season it will at leas offer us a good space opera story – even if it’s not exactly what its creator intended…

      Liked by 1 person

  3. I plan to watch season 1 in February. I’m confused about the utility of the whole cloned Cleon plot element which does not exist in the original Foundation saga. Also, I don’t understand the idea of a religious Demerzel. Has there been any hint of Demerzel having telepathic powers? I don’t mind spoilers.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. As far as I remember there were no indications that Demerzel possessed telepathic powers. And the Cleons’ genetic dynast was a (clever, IMHO) way of keeping the same “face” for the central power throughout the ages. Only the next season will tell us if this continuity “trick” keeps working.

      Like

  4. I haven’t watched the tv version of Foundation yet. But, I’ve always wondered how it could be successfully told in the medium. I’ll probably have issues with it like other diehard Asimovites, although a straight adaptation of the source material (at least the first three books) would be very boring, since most of the action was talked about instead of visualized. Still, I gotta watch it.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. From some of the reactions I read online, diehard Asimovites (I like that term!) have been *deeply* displeased by what they saw on screen, so you had better prepare yourself 😉 and I’d love to hear about your take on the show once you get the opportunity to see it!

      Liked by 1 person

  5. I’m so curious about this! I haven’t read Foundation but I know it’s one of those intimidating stories and I’ve always been reluctant to dive in. The show seems so ambitious, and I hope the next season will improve on some of the issues you had.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. After the announcement that this show was on the works I tried re-reading Asimov’s saga but I found it quite dry and word-heavy, so I’m not surprised that the series required some more… creativity there. Still, once I moved past the shaky beginning, it looked promising so… we’ll see 🙂

      Like

  6. Wholehearted agreement – Season One was such a frustrating watch, but I… find myself thinking about the characters, now, and curious to see where the narratives go next. In the end, it won me over even though I moaned the whole way through it about pacing and being kept at arm’s length (and I attribute a lot of my conversion to the Cleons’ shenanigans in the last 4 or so episodes, which was definitely the plot that worked best for me). Didn’t make me want to read the books though 😉

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I wonder if Asimov’s prose is still viable for our modern tastes: many of the hardcore fans “met” the books in their youth and kept the love alive, so they might still be able to enjoy it – My attempt at going back, after more than four decades proved to be a failure, so I can sympathize with your lack of interest for the books 😉

      Liked by 1 person

  7. I don’t have Apple+, so the chances of me watching this are low, but I loved every book in the Foundation series. I can see where some liberties with the story would need to be applied and, given your review, I don’t think I’ll mind the changes they made. The first part of Foundation felt like a long prologue to me anyway. (If my memory is correct. May have to go back and read it now!)

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I did try a re-read once the TV show’s production was announced, but discovered that time and changing tastes had turned what I remembered as an intriguing adventure into a plodding, ponderous tale I could not enjoy. It would be interesting to know how your re-read fares and if intervening time has changed your point of view as well or if the story feels as fresh and engaging as before 🙂

      Like

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.