I received this novel from Angry Robot Books through NetGalley, in exchange for an honest review: my thanks to both of them for this opportunity.
When last year I read S.T. Gibson A Dowry of Blood I was swept away by its unusual story and equally unusual narrative style, so that when Evocation was announced I was more than eager to sample this author’s new work.
David is the latest in a long line of famed magic wielders; as such he’s part of the “aristocracy” in the Boston magical scene: rich, handsome and successful in both his occult and mundane activities, he has everything one might desire – that is, until one day he realizes he’s the one who will have to pay the price for a demonic deal underwritten by one of his ancestors. Frantic to escape the fate that’s in store for him according to the terms of the deal, he has no other choice but to seek the help of another conjurer, his ex boyfriend Rhys, provided of course that they are able to mend the rift that brought to their violent breakup, and that David can overcome the strong objections of Moira, Rhys’ wife and a powerful medium, who can barely tolerate him.
As the three of them meet over the course of several days, trying to get to the source of what ails David, who suffers both physically and mentally from the demon’s onslaught, David’s jaunty façade begins to crumble, revealing many of his insecurities and past wounds, and the feelings between him and Rhys start to surface again, while Moira discovers that she can appreciate David’s company and starts building a strong bond of friendship with him. Their complex interactions also dovetail with some important changes in the Boston magical scene, while the pressure from the demon becomes almost unbearable and David’s life hangs in the balance….
I must confess that I had quite different expectations for this story: first and foremost, the synopsis hinted at a harrowing battle against powerful demonic forces, and at a deeper look into the influence of magic on our modern society, which this book presents as something quite natural. Unfortunately these elements are kept to the sidelines and the major focus of the novel is on the personal exchanges between David, Rhys and Moira and their slow journey toward a polyamorous relationship: granted, this latter element proved to be interesting, thanks to the exploration of the various dynamics of such a complex liaison and to the painful history of two of the concerned parties, but from my point of view it ended up taking the lion’s share of the narrative space, shunting the encroaching demonic danger to a corner, so that its weight on the characters and its resolution felt more like an afterthought than an integral part of the story.
And then there is the tone of the narrative itself, which is quite different from the opulent, almost lyrical writing I enjoyed in A Dowry of Blood: the story’s setting of course required a more modern form of expression, but I could not avoid constantly comparing its… mundane feel with the rich, beautiful writing that so captivated me in S.T. Gibson’s previous novel, so that I have to sadly admit that the overall feeling I was left with at the end of the book was that of wistful disappointment.
My hope, since this is the first in a series, is that the next books might recapture that special quality and offer a closer look into the layers of magic present in this vision of our modern world…
Well that’s disappointing because I have read an ARC of An Education in Malice and the beautiful writing was certainly what impressed me most!
LikeLiked by 1 person
So there is hope that An Education in Malice might cure my slight disappointment with this one! Good to know… 😉
LikeLike
I’m so sorry this didn’t work for you, but now I’m more curious than ever to read it. I’m going to be reading An Education in Malice soon so it will be interesting to compare the two.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The synopsis for An Education in Malice sounds promising, but right now I’m just a little wary of book blurbs, for obvious reasons… 😉
LikeLike
Oof this sounds disappointing! The lure of the blurb… We all fall prey to it 🙂 Hope your next read will be better, Maddalena!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Luckily for me, there is always greener grass just beyond the horizon… 😉
LikeLiked by 1 person
I agree with Sophie about the writing of An Education in Malice. I haven’t read A Dowry of Blood so I can’t do a comparison but in An Education the writing is beautiful and, almost, lyrical.
I am sorry this one disappointed you, it is always a shame when synopsis and book don’t agree, as to say!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Everyone who already read An Education in Malice confirmed – like you did – that the writing was more similar to the one in Dowry of Blood, and so… ahem… fortified I requested “Education” in the hope of forgetting the disappointment with this one… 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
I decided not to request this one – purely because I am determined to try and stay on track this year. It surprised me that the author had two releases expected – maybe it was too much. I agree with the comments above about the beautiful writing in An Education in Malice but it wasn’t enough to make me love the story.
Lynn 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
Evocation is far less cringe-worthy than “Malice”, but in the end it failed to captivate me…
LikeLike
Ahhh, I can see how the blurb tricked you into creating expectations that were finally unmet! I hope the next one proved to be a far more exciting read, Maddalena!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I guess I will be staying away from this author for a while now: two disappointments in as many books is a bit too much for my tastes… 😉
LikeLike