Review: WATCHING TREES GROW – Peter Hamilton

45254Peter Hamilton is one of those authors who always intimidated me through the sheer amount of published works combined with the staggering page count of each book: big volumes never scared me, far from it, but from the reviews I read I’ve learned that Hamilton’s Night Dawn trilogy, for example, represents quite a challenge, both in scope and in the quantity of characters and story-lines it contains.

So, when I saw he also published some shorter works, I decided to get my feet wet – so to speak – with something far less daunting before wading into the bigger ocean and this novella seemed like a good starting point. As far as careful approaches go, it was quite positive, and the best way to start on my journey with The 2016 Sci-Fi Experience, an event hosted by Carl  V. Anderson over at Stainless Steel Droppings (follow the links to know more!).

Watching Trees Grow is an alternate history tale based on the premise that the Roman Empire never fell, extending its influence all over the known world.   The action unfolds over a time period from 1832 to 2038, presenting some intriguing juxtaposition – like a turning dial, Bakelite telephone existing at the same time as battery-powered cars – together with quite fast technological progress that, by the end of the story, has brought mankind away from Earth in an expanding colonization effort throughout the galaxy.

The novella opens with the murder of a brilliant young student in Oxford: as a family representative, Edward Raleigh is called in to investigate the crime, but despite his best efforts he’s unable to find the perpetrator. This does not faze him, though, because the Empire has found a way to prolong its citizens’ lives and Edward knows time and scientific progress are on his side, so he keeps investigating the collected evidence through ever-improving means, with a relentless focus paired with the certainty he will ultimately succeed.

In the end the murder investigation is only the means through which Hamilton explores this alternate world, one where, for example, space exploration coexists with the Church’s heavy-handed influence on moral standards – there’s a running thread about the Borgias still ruling in Rome despite the general consensus about them having long overstayed their welcome.  The result is interesting, even though in places the dialogues appear somewhat stilted: Edward Raleigh and the people he deals with still retain a kind of old-fashioned speech pattern that’s somewhat reminiscent of the Victorian era, and that I found at odds with the evolving times and technology; there’s also a certain amount on explanatory exposition that looks back to the era in which the story begins, and tends to slow the narrative flow a little.

Despite these small ‘hiccups’ the novella remains appealing and it encouraged me to try something more from Peter Hamilton, especially other short stories I’ve found that should work as introduction to the universe where the author spent most of his time and craft.  So far, what I’ve encountered looks more than promising, and I’ll be back shortly with updates on my progress…

My Rating:



10 thoughts on “Review: WATCHING TREES GROW – Peter Hamilton

  1. I completely agree with you about the author intimidation! It’s often more of a case of not knowing where to start. I’ve always wanted to read Hamilton so, thanks to your review, I think this novella might be the way to go! 😀


    1. Happy to be of help! 🙂
      I just discovered another interesting short story “A Second Chance at Eden” that I believe works as an introduction to his greater work, and it’s *fascinating*: it’s quite possible that it will cure me of the author intimidation you speak of…

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Ah, Peter Hamilton, I need to read him too! But yep, total author intimidation. Where would I even start? I agree this sounds like a good place. I always like the idea of beginning with something shorter, so a novella would work just great. And ooh, anything related to the Roman Empire, I am so on board! 🙂


  3. I know the feeling..although for me the intimidation usually comes from the fact that most of his novels are HUGE, and I tend to get turned off by chunksters, even though my experience has told me that they can be quite engaging. I have read part of Great North Road, and was enjoying what I read, but I still find it easy to get distracted by shorter books, which is why I have yet to finish it.


    1. I know what you mean: when I was younger and had more free time on my hands, huge books were my preferred fare. Now, if they require a longer commitment, I need to think about it… But right now I’m more curious than worried, so I guess I’m ready to take the plunge 🙂


  4. I have so many Peter Hamilton books on my TBR shelf that I want to get to, but you’re right, his books are so large and involving, it’s hard to get started. I am mostly done with the Pandora’s Star series. One book left. Once I knock that one off, I want to read more of his work, because although the books are big, they do read quickly.


    1. It’s true, they are a fast read: I started “The Reality Dysfunction” and I’m literally devouring it – and wondering why I did wait so long 🙂
      On the plus side I must add that, despite a huge character list, one never gets lost in his world, and that’s the mark of a good story-teller.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.